See Alistair's review of this book here.
I confess I was somewhat less overwhelmingly charmed by this book than was my husband. In fact, I had a great deal of difficulty getting through it, because while the plot and characterization and twisty little side journeys are all as pleasingly eccentric as Alistair's review led me to believe they would be, my tolerance for puns is quite low, with the exception of the occasional very-clever specimen, and this book is absolutely littered with the damned things. Scarcely a one of the ludicrously-short chapters went by without my giving a heartfelt groan and having to set the book aside for some several minutes to recover. Now, this did wonders for my general productivity during the span of time in which I was reading this book, but did not serve to speed my progress through the pages.
In summary, I think I'd have to say that the book was incredibly disappointing. It had tremendous promise, and taken as a whole I really did enjoy it. However, I really think it could have been great, had its author not spent quite so much effort trying to look clever by means of excessively-florid wordplay, and instead simply relied on the strength of the actual cleverness that the book is built from.
Oh, and as a mostly-irrelevant aside, I don't know where this book may have been stored before it was shipped to us as an Early Reviewer copy, but it smelled so strongly of patchouli upon arrival that even now, months after the fact, when I flipped through it in a quick re-familiarization, it was able to give me a headache. Yikes.
Recent Comments